You have an employee who seems to question everything you do. You announce a new procedure, and they’ve got objections. You explain a decision in your one-on-one, and suddenly you’re spending fifteen minutes defending it. In meetings, they’re challenging your reasoning while everyone watches. You’re all for questions and honest feedback, but when practically every conversation turns into a debate, it’s exhausting. Today we’re talking about what to do when an employee constantly pushes back, and how to handle it without getting defensive or turning every conversation into a power struggle. Whether you’re a manager, team leader, or simply responsible for getting work done through other people, this one’s for you.
12-minute read
When Every Decision Becomes a Debate, There’s a Bigger Problem
I want to start by making an important distinction. Having an employee question your decisions occasionally is a good thing. You want people who think critically, identify problems, and bring you information you might not have. You don’t want a team of people who simply agree with everything you say.
But that’s very different from having an employee who questions nearly everything you do. It’s a problem when every assignment comes with an objection or every deadline needs to be justified. Or maybe you’ve discussed something and made a decision, but they keep bringing it up and finding more reasons to debate.
At some point, this isn’t about healthy disagreement anymore. It’s a problem in the working relationship, and yes, it might be an issue of respect. They might not respect your judgment, accept your authority, or recognize the boundaries of their role. They might believe they should have more influence over decisions than their position allows. And you can have a problem with respect even when someone is perfectly polite. If an employee treats every decision you make as something they’re entitled to renegotiate, there’s an issue that needs to be addressed.
Four Psychological Reasons Employees Question Everything
In my experience working with organizations and leaders, I’ve found four main psychological reasons someone might constantly question or challenge the person leading them. Understanding what’s driving the behavior can help you figure out how to address it.
1. They Have a Strong Need for Control
Some people have difficulty tolerating uncertainty or decisions they didn’t help make. When they don’t understand every detail or can’t influence the outcome, they become uncomfortable. Questioning everything is a way they’re trying to gain control.
Maybe you’ve assigned a project with a particular deadline, and the employee immediately wants to know why it can’t be done differently. You explain, but they bring up another alternative. And then another. Their problem might have less to do with the deadline and more to do with their discomfort about not being the one making the decision.
2. They’re Struggling with Their Position in the Hierarchy
Maybe they’re highly experienced and believe they know more than you. Maybe they wanted your job. Maybe they were accustomed to having greater authority in a previous position, or before you took over, and now they’re having difficulty accepting their current role.
They might believe their experience entitles them to more decision-making power than they have. And when you make a decision without their approval, they experience that as a slight. Their objections become a way of trying to establish their own authority.
3. They Don’t Trust or Respect Your Judgment
Maybe they don’t believe you’re qualified to make certain decisions. Maybe they’ve lost confidence in you because of something that’s happened in the past. Or maybe they simply don’t accept that you’re going to make decisions they don’t agree with.
And sometimes, this lack of respect is related to who you are rather than anything you’ve done. Maybe they question your authority because you’re a woman, a person of color, younger than they are, or simply don’t fit their idea of what a leader should look like. (We’ll come back to this in a minute when we talk about identifying patterns).
4. They’ve Learned That Challenging Everything Works
Maybe previous managers consistently gave in when they pushed back. Maybe they discovered that if they object long enough, someone else will take over the assignment, change the deadline, or eventually let them have their way.
And sometimes the employee has learned that arguing is how you get attention or establish influence. They might not even recognize how disruptive the behavior has become.
Of course, these four reasons aren’t mutually exclusive. Someone might struggle with control and have trouble accepting your authority. I’m pretty sure I’ve worked with people who have all four.
Look at the Pattern Before You Respond
Before deciding how to approach this employee, I want you to do a little detective work. I want you to ask yourself these five questions:
- How often does this happen? Is it an occasional disagreement, or does nearly every conversation turn into a debate?
- When does it happen? Is it primarily during team meetings? One-on-ones? When you assign work, establish deadlines, or make decisions that affect them personally?
- What are they questioning? Do they bring up new information or legitimate concerns? Or do they repeatedly challenge decisions after they’ve been discussed and explained?
- What happens afterward? Do they accept the decision and complete the work, or do they continue resisting, delaying implementation, or reopening the same argument? Do you end up seeing passive-aggressive behavior, or are they seemingly happy?
- Do they behave this way with everyone? Do they question other leaders or only you? Do they respond differently to men and women? To people of different ages, races, or levels of seniority?
That last question, do they behave this way with everyone? deserves particular attention. I’m sure you won’t be surprised to learn that research has found that women in a traditionally male-dominated profession experience more frequent challenges to their authority and professional roles than their male colleagues. And because this behavior will keep happening, women are more likely to report burnout over time.
So, if you’ve noticed that an employee questions your decisions but readily accepts similar decisions from someone else, don’t automatically dismiss what you’re seeing or think you’re overreacting. It’s likely there’s some bias going on that you need to consider.
Obviously, one incident doesn’t establish a pattern, but if you’re noticing repeated differences in how someone responds to you or another leader, you should take note.
I’m going to discuss the challenges women face in management and leadership in a separate episode, but for now, pay attention to who gets questioned, when, and how.
Why You’re Having the Same Conversation Over and Over
Now we get to the meat of today’s talk. Every conversation has two layers. The first is the content: the facts, explanations, and specific issue being discussed. The second is the relationship layer, which is what’s happening emotionally between the people having the conversation. Communication researchers have long described how these two layers work together, and how it’s the relationship that has the most influence regarding how someone hears that content or what’s getting said.
So, let’s say you’ve asked an employee to finish a report by Thursday. They question the deadline. You explain why you need it. They argue that Friday would make more sense. You explain that leadership needs the report Thursday morning. They bring up everything else they’re working on. You explain the priorities again. And now you’re going around in circles.
You think you’re discussing a deadline, but something else is happening underneath. Maybe the employee resents being told what to do. Maybe they believe you don’t appreciate how much work they’re doing. Maybe they don’t trust your decisions or respect your authority. Or maybe they’re trying to establish that you can’t simply assign something without getting their agreement.
Meanwhile, you’re getting increasingly frustrated because you feel like your authority is being questioned!
You’re both arguing about Thursday versus Friday, but the real problem isn’t the deadline. It’s what’s happening in the relationship! Our feelings drive our behavior, not our logic. If logic drove behavior, I’d be a size 2 gym bunny with washboard abs. If logic drove behavior, not feelings, no one would smoke cigarettes, drink alcohol, or eat Oreos. We’d all be meditating an hour a day, never touch our phones other than to make a call, and everyone would drive a Toyota Corolla.
No, my friend. It’s feelings and desires that run the show, and those are largely unconscious (scary to think about, actually). So, you can explain the facts until you’re blue in the face, but if the real issue is resentment, insecurity, distrust, or a power struggle, your perfectly logical explanation is never going to solve anything.
You have to address the relationship, not keep arguing about the content. I’ll say that again because I love you. You have to address the relationship, not keep arguing about the content. And that requires doing something most people find uncomfortable: naming what’s happening between you.
And you can do that in just two simple steps (they’re simple, but I didn’t say they were easy so pay attention).
Step One: Interrupt the Pattern
The next time you realize you’re having essentially the same conversation again, stop. I mean it. I want you to literally stop the conversation.
You might say, “Can we stop for a minute? I’m noticing that a lot of our conversations go this way. I make a decision, you question it, I explain my reasoning, and we keep going back and forth. This is clearly not about the deadline anymore.”
Now you’ve interrupted the familiar pattern. You’re no longer trying to come up with a better explanation of why Thursday matters.
Step Two: Address What’s Happening Between You
Once you’ve stopped discussing the content, you can explore the relationship.
You might say, “There’s something happening in how we’re working together that’s making these decisions difficult. Do you feel like I’m not hearing your input? Is there something about how I’m leading that you’re struggling with?”
Or you can be more direct: “I’m wondering if you’re having a hard time trusting my judgment on these decisions. Is that something we need to talk about?”
You’re not accusing the employee of being resentful or telling them what they’re feeling. You’re asking about the underlying issue.
They might tell you they don’t feel heard. They might say they think their experience is being overlooked. Maybe they’ll acknowledge that they don’t agree with your management style or that they’re frustrated about something that’s happened previously. Whatever the answer, you’ve got something more useful to work with than another argument about a deadline.
And if they say, “There’s no problem. I’m just asking questions,” don’t get pulled back into debating their intentions.
You can say, “I understand that’s how you see it. I’m talking about the pattern and the impact it’s having on our work. We’re spending a lot of time going over decisions we’ve already discussed, and that’s something we need to change.”
You don’t need the employee to agree with your interpretation of what’s happening between you. You need to be able to have a productive working relationship.
Once you’ve understood what’s happening between you, be clear about what needs to change. You can welcome questions and disagreement without allowing every decision to become a negotiation. And if the behavior continues after you’ve addressed it directly, it’s time for accountability. Document specific examples and follow through with your organization’s procedures.
If you want to know exactly what to say when an employee pushes back in different situations, get today’s free download, which is full of useful scripts with exact language for those hard moments.
How to Keep Yourself from Getting Defensive
Now, even when the employee’s behavior is a genuine problem, your reaction can make the situation better or worse.
When someone questions you constantly, you can start anticipating resistance before they’ve even opened their mouth. You’re irritated, and you’ve already got your arguments lined up. Now even a reasonable question can sound like another challenge.
Research has found that managers who feel less confident in their own competence can become more resistant to employee input. If this is you, you’re going to be less inclined to seek out suggestions from your employees and you’re going to be more likely to reject information if you think it threatens your sense of competence. And there’s an added complication when other people are watching. Research has found that managers can become more defensive when employees raise challenging suggestions publicly rather than privately, especially when the relationship is already strained.
So before responding, ask yourself, “Am I defending this decision, or am I defending my image?” If you’re trying to prove you’re right, you’re probably not listening very well. What do I always say? Listen like you’re wrong. That doesn’t mean assume you’re wrong. It means listen with the possibility that the other person knows something you don’t.
As with so much I talk about, if you’re not being mindful, you’re going to suck at this. If you’re not in the moment, noticing your reaction (“Hey, this person is really upsetting me”), you’re not going to remember any of the great tools I’ve taught you or even pause long enough to use one. If you haven’t gotten my free Mindfulness Starter Kit by now, just know that you’re killing me slowly.
Make It Clear When Decisions Are Open for Discussion
One last thing that can prevent some of these problems is being clear about when you want input and when you’ve already made a decision. If you’re asking for ideas, say, “I’m considering a few different approaches, and I want your thoughts before I decide.”
If you’re looking for potential problems, say, “Here’s the direction I’m leaning. What concerns should I consider?”
And when a decision has been made, say, “We’ve decided to move forward with this approach. I want to answer questions and make sure everyone understands what happens next.”
Those are three different conversations, and your employees should know which one they’re having. You can remain open to important new information without making every decision a group vote.
Put Today’s Lesson into Action
The next time an employee pushes back, I want you to notice whether this is an isolated disagreement or part of a larger pattern. If it’s a pattern, stop trying to win the individual argument and address what’s happening in the relationship.
To help you handle these conversations, grab my free What to Say When an Employee Questions Everything cheat sheet. It gives you ready-to-use scripts for handling repeated objections, public challenges, disrespect, and the bigger conversation about an ongoing pattern. Keep it handy for your next difficult conversation.
Resources
References
- Williams, M. J., Esianor, B., Hendrick, S., Farlow, J. L., Farrell, A., Kupfer, R. A., Meyer, T. K., Vinson, K. N., Wandell, G. M., & Chen, A. Y. (2025). Everyday challenges to women’s presence and authority yield greater burnout and less persistence in a male-dominated profession. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(20), e2415826122.
- Watzlawick, P., Beavin, J. H., & Jackson, D. D. (1967). Pragmatics of Human Communication: A Study of Interactional Patterns, Pathologies, and Paradoxes. W. W. Norton.
- Fast, N. J., Burris, E. R., & Bartel, C. A. (2014). Managing to stay in the dark: Managerial self-efficacy, ego defensiveness, and the aversion to employee voice. Academy of Management Journal, 57(4), 1013–1034.
- Isaakyan, S., Sherf, E. N., Tangirala, S., & Guenter, H. (2021). Keeping it between us: Managerial endorsement of public versus private voice. Journal of Applied Psychology, 106(7), 1049–1066.
- Burris, E. R. (2012). The risks and rewards of speaking up: Managerial responses to employee voice. Academy of Management Journal, 55(4), 851–875.





